Cloé Fonteix, avocat

Criminal asset seizure and confiscation

Criminal seizure and international mutual legal assistance

Assets targeted by a criminal investigation are often located in several countries. A seizure may therefore be ordered in France at the request of a foreign authority (incoming request) or abroad at the request of a French judge or prosecutor (outgoing request). In both cases, the applicable rules, the competent courts and the time limits for challenges depend on the States involved and the instruments binding them.

First question: is the State concerned a member of the European Union?

Between EU Member States, seizures circulate through mutual recognition, as freezing orders governed by Regulation (EU) 2018/1805. This regime is covered on a dedicated page: Enforcement in France of a foreign freezing or seizure order.

With other States, such as Monaco, Switzerland or the United Kingdom, a seizure requires a request for mutual legal assistance, based on the applicable bilateral or multilateral conventions and, failing that, on the French Code of Criminal Procedure.

Incoming request: seizure ordered in France at the request of a foreign State

In the absence of an international convention providing otherwise, Articles 694-10 to 694-13 of the Code of Criminal Procedure govern foreign requests for mutual legal assistance seeking the seizure of assets with a view to their subsequent confiscation. Enforcement is ordered by the investigating judge, on application by or after hearing the public prosecutor, in accordance with the procedures of the Code of Criminal Procedure: the seizure therefore takes the form of a domestic criminal seizure, in particular a special seizure (Articles 706-141 et seq.).

The request is rejected if one of the grounds for refusal applicable to the enforcement of foreign confiscations (Article 713-37) is already established, for example where the asset cannot be confiscated under French law or the foreign proceedings do not offer sufficient safeguards for the rights of the defence.

In a judgment of 9 June 2022 (No. 21-82.780), the Criminal Chamber held that the person targeted by the request is entitled to appeal against the investigating judge’s order directing the seizure. The appeal then follows the regime of the seizure ordered: for a seizure of real estate or intangible assets, within ten days of notification, before the investigation chamber (chambre de l’instruction).

Outgoing request: seizure requested by France abroad

Where a French investigating judge or prosecutor wishes to have an asset located outside France seized, they issue a freezing certificate within the European Union, or send a request for mutual legal assistance to the authorities of the State concerned.

The challenge then takes place on two levels:

Coordination is essential: where assets are seized abroad, the defence requires working with a lawyer in the executing State, in order to align the remedies, time limits and arguments on both sides.

Monaco and Luxembourg: two distinct regimes

Franco-Monegasque and Franco-Luxembourg cases are frequent. They are not governed by the same rules: Luxembourg, an EU Member State, applies Regulation (EU) 2018/1805; Monaco, which is not an EU member, falls under traditional mutual legal assistance and the conventions binding it to France. Identifying the correct regime is the first step of any challenge.

What documents should be gathered?

The request for mutual legal assistance or the freezing certificate, the French order, notifications received in France and abroad, proof of ownership and of the origin of funds, and any decision issued in the foreign State. Translation of documents should be planned in advance.

Frequently asked questions

Who can challenge a seizure ordered in France at the request of a foreign State?
The person targeted by the request for mutual legal assistance, as well as third parties with rights over the asset, under the conditions laid down for the seizure ordered.

Do I need a lawyer in each of the two countries?
Often, yes: each court only reviews part of the measure, and the time limits for challenges run separately.

Related publications (in French)

Legal references

Contact

Cloé Fonteix – Haïk & Associés (AARPI), 15 rue Soufflot, 75005 Paris, France. Tel.: +33 1 43 25 73 73; c.fonteix@cabinethaik.com.

General information only; this page does not constitute legal advice.