Criminal asset seizure and confiscation
Criminal seizure of real estate: what remedies?
A criminal seizure of real estate makes a property unavailable during the proceedings, sometimes long before any judgment. It may affect a home, a building held by a property company (société civile immobilière, SCI), or property held jointly or in split ownership. The defence concerns both the legal basis of the measure and its consequences for the owner’s assets.
A property can be seized from the investigation stage
Article 706-150 of the Code of Criminal Procedure allows, during the investigation, the liberty and custody judge (juge des libertés et de la détention) seised by the prosecution, or the investigating judge during a judicial investigation, to order by reasoned decision the seizure of a property whose confiscation is provided for by law. The decision is notified to the owner and to third parties with known rights over the property.
Registration of the seizure makes it enforceable against third parties. The property remains, in principle, owned by its holder, but acts of disposal and civil enforcement proceedings are affected by the rules in Articles 706-145 to 706-152.
Challenging the real estate seizure order
An appeal against the decision provided for in Article 706-150 must, in principle, be lodged within ten days of notification before the investigation chamber (chambre de l’instruction). It does not suspend the seizure. The arguments vary depending on whether the measure is based on ownership by the suspect, on the suspect’s free disposal of a property held by a third party, on the proceeds of the offence or on a seizure of equivalent value.
The situation of an SCI, a joint owner or a bare owner calls for an individual assessment. The title deed does not always settle the matter: case law also looks at the reality of the powers exercised over the property and, where relevant, the good faith of the apparent owner.
In a judgment of 15 January 2025 (No. 24-80.694), the Cour de cassation restated the requirements for establishing free disposal, the bad faith of third parties and the proportionality review in a case of split ownership in favour of minor children. This litigation illustrates the need to distinguish between usufruct and bare ownership.
Can a property be sold while it is under seizure?
The voluntary sale of a seized property is not an ordinary real estate transaction. Article 706-152 provides for certain mechanisms transferring the seizure to the sale price and allows, under specific conditions, an early sale authorised by the judge for the benefit of AGRASC (the French agency for the management and recovery of seized and confiscated assets). This must be distinguished from confiscation, which has not yet been ordered.
Early sale: the constitutional reservation of October 2026
In its decision No. 2026-1224 QPC of 8 October 2026, the Conseil constitutionnel issued an important interpretative reservation: an early sale may not be authorised where the owner has not failed to maintain the property and is able to bear its upkeep costs. Both elements must be documented in concrete terms. A general interest in keeping one’s property is not enough.
The decision also accepts that a challenge to an authorisation to sell may be examined without a hearing as a matter of course, provided that the judge ensures, in the circumstances of the case, that a hearing is not necessary for the fairness of the proceedings and the rights of the defence. A challenge to an early sale must not be confused with an appeal against the initial seizure.
To contest a proposed sale, documents relating to maintenance expenses, the condition of the property, foreseeable charges and available resources may be decisive.
Creditors, mortgages and criminal seizure
In principle, a criminal seizure stays or prevents civil enforcement proceedings against the same property (Article 706-145). Article 706-146 allows certain creditors holding an enforceable title to be authorised to proceed. In a judgment of 15 January 2025 (No. 23-85.073), the Criminal Chamber clarified the review carried out by the judge where a creditor seeks to continue enforcement. I have devoted an analysis of this judgment in Dalloz actualité.
Frequently asked questions
Can an SCI defend a property it owns?
Yes, depending on its rights and procedural standing. The analysis must distinguish between legal personality, legal ownership and the possible free disposal of the property by a suspect.
Does an early sale end the seizure?
Not necessarily: depending on the applicable regime, the measure may be transferred to the proceeds of the sale, which are placed on deposit.
Related publications (in French)
- Démembrement de la propriété : appréciation (très facilitée) de la libre disposition et de la bonne foi du mineur — Dalloz actualité, 17 March 2025.
- La prééminence procédurale de la saisie pénale sur les voies d’exécution civiles — Dalloz actualité, 11 February 2025.
- Constitutionnalité du régime de mise en vente par l’AGRASC des biens saisis et aliénés — Dalloz actualité, 8 October 2025.
Legal references
- Articles 706-141 to 706-158 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
- Conseil constitutionnel, 8 October 2026, No. 2026-1224 QPC
- Article 131-21 of the Criminal Code
Contact
Cloé Fonteix – Haïk & Associés (AARPI), 15 rue Soufflot, 75005 Paris, France. Tel.: +33 1 43 25 73 73; c.fonteix@cabinethaik.com.
General information only; this page does not constitute legal advice.
