Cloé Fonteix, avocat

Criminal asset seizure and confiscation

Criminal confiscation: the rights of the third-party owner

An asset may be seized and then confiscated in criminal proceedings brought against someone else. The spouse, the business partner, the owning company, the creditor or the holder of split ownership rights must be able to assert their rights within an appropriate procedural framework.

Legal ownership does not settle every question

Article 131-21 of the French Criminal Code provides for several grounds of confiscation. Depending on the ground relied on, the court may have to examine not only the title of ownership but also the convicted person’s free disposal of the asset and the good faith of the third party. It is necessary to distinguish the rights over the asset, each person’s role in acquiring it and the powers actually exercised over it.

The third party’s defence begins with a reconstruction of the asset situation: acquisition deeds, financing, corporate decisions, management powers, agreements between the persons involved and the circumstances in which the asset was used.

How far does good faith go?

Good faith does not have the same practical meaning in every situation. It is assessed in light of the type of confiscation and the facts characterising the situation of the claimed owner. The existence of a separate company or of a notarial deed is not necessarily sufficient, on its own, to rule out a debate on real economic ownership.

In a judgment of 4 September 2024 (No. 23-81.981), the Criminal Chamber held that a third party seeking the return of a confiscated asset through an enforcement dispute (incident contentieux d’exécution) may challenge the convicted person’s free disposal of the asset and assert their good faith. In that specific context, however, the third party has no standing to challenge the legal basis or the reasoning of the penalty imposed on the convicted person. A practical consequence follows: the remedy and the available arguments must be determined together.

Spouses, joint ownership, usufruct and bare ownership

The seizure of jointly owned property is not always limited to the share supposedly belonging to the suspect. The judgment of 13 November 2025 (No. 24-83.199) concerning a joint bank account illustrates that the funds may be seized in full, without automatic release of half in favour of the co-holder acting in good faith. The latter’s rights must be protected through the appropriate procedures, in particular those relating to return of property and, depending on the case, to partition.

Split ownership raises different difficulties. On 15 January 2025 (No. 24-80.694), the Cour de cassation restated that, in the case of a seizure of an estate covering an asset freely disposed of by the suspect, the judges must establish the situation of the third parties and carry out the required proportionality review. Holding the usufruct is not enough to merge the rights of the bare owner with those of the usufructuary.

What can be done once confiscation has been ordered?

The framework changes after the trial judgment. Depending on the third party’s status, the procedure followed and the point at which they were able to defend their interests, an appeal against the decision or an enforcement dispute may be considered. The procedure does not necessarily allow the whole debate on someone else’s guilt or penalty to be reopened.

The issues may be international. Regarding the enforcement in France of a foreign confiscation, the judgment of 24 September 2025 (No. 22-81.067) highlights the weight of the review of third-party rights already carried out by the foreign court, where the required procedural safeguards were ensured. Within the European Union, the recognition of freezing and confiscation orders is also governed by specific instruments, in particular Regulation (EU) 2018/1805. See also Enforcement in France of a foreign freezing or seizure order.

What documents help defend the third party’s rights?

Useful evidence may include title deeds, deeds of gift or partition, contracts, financing records, accounts, corporate decisions, documents relating to the use of the asset and proof of the steps taken during the proceedings. It is also important to trace the notifications received and the opportunities given to the third party to present observations.

Frequently asked questions

I am not being prosecuted: can my asset still be seized?
Yes, in the cases provided for by law. The provisional nature of the seizure and the absence of proceedings against the owner are not, on their own, enough to obtain its release.

Does an SCI necessarily protect its building from confiscation?
No. Legal personality and title deeds are important, but real economic ownership, free disposal and good faith may be debated depending on the ground of confiscation.

Related publications (in French)

Legal references

Contact

Cloé Fonteix – Haïk & Associés (AARPI), 15 rue Soufflot, 75005 Paris, France. Tel.: +33 1 43 25 73 73; c.fonteix@cabinethaik.com.

General information only; this page does not constitute legal advice.