Criminal asset seizure and confiscation
Release of a criminal seizure and return of property
Recovering a seized asset does not always mean waiting for the end of the trial. The application must, however, be made to the right judicial authority, on the right legal basis, distinguishing between the return of an object, the release of a special seizure and a challenge to a decision to sell.
Release and return: two distinct concepts
Release (mainlevée) brings a seizure to an end; return (restitution) seeks to give an object or asset held by the justice system back to the person entitled to it. The two steps may be linked, but their conditions and remedies are not always the same.
The issue may concern a bank account, funds, a vehicle, jewellery, digital assets, a property or professional equipment. Whether the asset can be returned depends, among other things, on its usefulness for the investigation and on whether it may be confiscated.
To which judicial authority should the application be made?
During the investigation, or where no court is seised of the case, Article 41-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure gives the public prosecutor or the prosecutor general certain powers to return property. Where a decision refusing return is made, the provision allows a challenge before the first president of the court of appeal or a judge delegated by them, within one month of its notification.
During a judicial investigation, Article 99 allows an application to be made to the investigating judge for the return of objects held by the justice system. A specific system of remedies applies to the judge’s order.
For applications relating to the enforcement of a special seizure, Article 706-144 designates the competent judge according to the stage of the proceedings. Specific rules apply once the trial court is seised. The type of seizure must therefore be checked before choosing the procedure.
Can an application be made before judgment?
Yes, depending on the asset concerned and the legal conditions. Keeping a seizure in place until the end of the proceedings is not automatically justified. The application must be substantiated: identity of the owner, origin of the asset or funds, absence of any need for its retention, and arguments specific to the legal basis of the seizure.
A refusal to return property must also be distinguished from a sale before judgment. A sale may create an irreversible situation, even where its proceeds remain on deposit. I have analysed in Dalloz actualité several decisions concerning the sale of assets held by the justice system.
The return application must be examined before certain sales
In a judgment of 16 September 2026 (No. 26-80.554) concerning seized animals, the Criminal Chamber held that, where the first president is seised at the same time of a challenge to a refusal to return and of a challenge to the transfer of the animals, they may not rule on the transfer before ruling on the refusal to return. This solution aims to preserve the effectiveness of judicial review, subject to the admissibility of the challenges.
The Conseil constitutionnel, in decision No. 2025-1156 QPC of 12 September 2025, also examined the safeguards surrounding the sale by AGRASC (the French agency for the management and recovery of seized and confiscated assets) of seized assets: informing the owner and the economic conditions of the sale are concerns distinct from the initial seizure.
Beware of time limits after the proceedings are closed
Article 41-4 provides, in the situations it governs, that where no return has been requested or ordered within six months of certain decisions closing the proceedings, unreturned objects may become the property of the State, subject to the rights of third parties. This rule calls for particular vigilance: its exact application depends on the status of the asset, the decision that closed the proceedings and the rights claimed.
To gather for the first review: seizure decision, any refusal to return, notifications, proof of ownership, documents showing the origin of the funds and a chronology of the steps already taken.
Frequently asked questions
Does an acquittal automatically mean that all assets are returned?
No. It is necessary to check what the court decided, the status of the objects retained and the time limits for requesting their return.
Can I ask to recover an asset while the investigation is still ongoing?
An application is possible in certain frameworks, but its outcome depends in particular on the asset’s relevance to establishing the truth and on whether it may be confiscated.
Related publications (in French)
- Animal saisi puis vendu : primauté à l’examen de la restitution — Dalloz actualité, 8 October 2026.
- Constitutionnalité du régime de mise en vente par l’AGRASC des biens saisis et aliénés — Dalloz actualité, 8 October 2025.
- Compte courant détenu en indivision avec un tiers de bonne foi : une saisie pénale non divisible — Dalloz actualité, 26 November 2025.
Legal references
- Article 41-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
- Article 99 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
- Articles 706-141 to 706-158 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
Contact
Cloé Fonteix – Haïk & Associés (AARPI), 15 rue Soufflot, 75005 Paris, France. Tel.: +33 1 43 25 73 73; c.fonteix@cabinethaik.com.
General information only; this page does not constitute legal advice.
